The controversies surrounding soccer’s video assistant referee (VAR) system spotlight our troubled relationship with uncertainty – and level to potential options
Liverpool followers jostle for a have a look at the on-field VAR display at Anfield stadium Alex Dodd – CameraSport by way of Getty Pictures
In case you have watched any football – or soccer – over the previous few years, you’ll know that the sport has been consumed by controversies over its new refereeing know-how. The video assistant referee (VAR) system was launched to the English Premier League in 2019 to cut back refereeing errors and get extra selections proper. As an alternative, it has created new sorts of uncertainty and undermined our understanding of basic guidelines like offside and handball. It has additionally infuriated followers, who can usually be heard chanting “it’s not soccer any extra” after a long-winded VAR examine.
It’s truthful to say that soccer followers wish to get irate, particularly when refereeing selections go towards their workforce. However as I argue in my new e book, I Can’t Cease Considering About VAR, there’s extra to this than meets the attention. As somebody whose job entails creating new strategies of measuring instructional attainment, I’ve thought lengthy and exhausting concerning the explanation why VAR has been so irritating. I imagine its issues relate to the problem of pinning down objective reality, the problem of exact measurement and the human dislike of uncertainty.
What I’ve additionally come to grasp, nonetheless, is that VAR exemplifies the boundaries of rationality in lots of walks of life far past the soccer subject. As such, a quick exploration of the history of measurement extra broadly – from makes an attempt to pin down the boiling level of water within the 18th century to the battle to precisely assess the…
Technology
