Most individuals anticipated the Pittsburgh Steelers to blow out the New York Giants, however the sport really sport down the wire. It wasn’t just like the Steelers’ offense wasn’t making performs both. George Pickens had two touchdowns within the 26-18 win known as again, and had they counted, the sport could have been much less irritating. The second play was truly backbreaking, with Pickens tapping one foot twice, however not getting his different foot down, leading to an incompletion. Analyst Mike Florio believes that the rule must be given a protracted look.
“It doesn’t matter in the event you’re hopping round on one foot,” Florio stated Tuesday on his Pro Football Talk podcast. “You may hop all the way in which down the sector. You catch a move, and you’ll pogo stick all the way in which down the sector. If the opposite foot by no means hits the bottom, the catch has by no means been made, by rule.
“Possibly they want to take a look at that rule. Possibly two toes, not each toes, two steps, not each toes. In case you have it lengthy sufficient to take two steps with the identical leg, possibly that needs to be sufficient for it to be a catch.”
That’s an fascinating suggestion. Over time, the NFL has altered the rule on what’s and isn’t a catch a number of instances. Even in spite of everything of that, it nonetheless isn’t completely clear what constitutes a reception generally. Steelers followers seemingly bear in mind all of the controversy surrounding Jesse James’ failed touchdown towards the New England Patriots.
Issues have gotten barely clearer since then, however generally, a play will likely be dominated not a catch that leaves among the viewers confused. By rule, Pickens’ landing mustn’t have counted, however many will argue that it ought to have. Pickens didn’t tap his other foot, however he did management the ball and faucet one foot twice.
Maybe the NFL might change the rule, or at the least check out it this offseason. If a participant controls the ball and has the time to faucet one foot twice, possibly it ought to rely as a catch.
Nevertheless, that is likely to be a can of worms the NFL doesn’t wish to open. If it tweaks the catch rule barely this time, then when will the adjustments finish? Would that sort of change simply make soccer extra sophisticated? There’s most likely an excessive amount of uncertainty round what would occur for the NFL to truly alter the rule.
It’s not like that a part of the rule is an issue both. Tapping two toes appears superb. You could possibly argue that Pickens ought to have had the wherewithal to deliver his different foot down. That’s most likely simpler stated than executed, however receivers have made way more inconceivable toe faucets up to now. Simply look at Santonio Holmes.
In the end, the play didn’t price the Steelers, and now everybody ought to have a stable understanding that it’s each toes, not one foot twice. If each rule bought modified as a result of a freak play uncovered a flaw, then the NFL can be unrecognizable.
