Connect with us

Hi, what are you looking for?

NFL

Matt Ryan Named NFL’s Most Clutch Quarterback in New Study, Ahead of Tom Brady and Matthew Stafford

Matt Ryan Named NFL’s Most Clutch Quarterback in New Study, Ahead of Tom Brady and Matthew Stafford When the game is on the line, which NFL quarterbacks can be counted on to deliver? New research has ranked the league’s most clutch passers over the past five seasons, with some surprising names emerging ahead of Patrick

Matt Ryan Named NFL’s Most Clutch Quarterback in New Study, Ahead of Tom Brady and Matthew Stafford

Matt Ryan Falcons Fantasy Duds
Matt Ryan Named NFL’s Most Clutch Quarterback in New Study, Ahead of Tom Brady and Matthew Stafford

When the game is on the line, which NFL quarterbacks can be counted on to deliver? New research has ranked the league’s most clutch passers over the past five seasons, with some surprising names emerging ahead of Patrick Mahomes and Josh Allen.

New research from Lucky Rebel reveals the NFL’s most clutch quarterbacks, based on an analysis of 1,359 regular-season games between 2021 and 2025. The study examined quarterback performances in the fourth quarter and overtime when games were separated by eight points or fewer.

The research assessed 38 qualifying quarterbacks across several measures, including passing efficiency, game-winning drives, performance under pressure, crucial down conversions, and ball security.

Former Atlanta Falcons quarterback Matt Ryan claimed the top spot with a Clutch Score of 97.11 out of 100, followed by seven-time Super Bowl champion Tom Brady (91.97) and Los Angeles Rams quarterback Matthew Stafford (80.46).

Matt Ryan and Tom Brady Lead the NFL’s Clutch Rankings

Ryan’s position at the top may surprise some NFL fans, but his late-game statistics tell a compelling story.

Advertisement. Scroll to continue reading.

Across 164 clutch dropbacks during the study period, Ryan completed 74.1% of his passes, throwing nine touchdowns against just one interception. His passer rating climbed to 116.71 in clutch situations, an improvement of nearly 34 points compared to other game situations.

Brady finished second with a score of 91.97, recording 12 passing touchdowns and just one interception across 227 clutch dropbacks. The former New England Patriots and Tampa Bay Buccaneers quarterback also achieved the highest ball-security score in the study.

Despite both quarterbacks having retired, their performances during the five-year window were enough to keep them ahead of the league’s current stars.

Matthew Stafford Leads Quarterbacks Who Played in 2025, With Dak Prescott and Joe Burrow Close Behind

Among quarterbacks who played during the 2025 season, Stafford emerged as the most clutch, ranking third overall with a score of 80.46.

The Rams veteran threw 25 touchdowns against five interceptions across 358 clutch dropbacks, producing a passer rating of 110.56.

Advertisement. Scroll to continue reading.

His passer rating also increased by 13.59 points in close, late-game situations, suggesting Stafford becomes even more effective when the pressure rises.

Dallas Cowboys quarterback Dak Prescott ranked fifth overall with a score of 76.97, followed by Cincinnati Bengals star Joe Burrow in sixth with 73.36.

Burrow was particularly impressive in the final five minutes of close games, leading all qualifying quarterbacks with 0.321 expected points added (EPA) per dropback. He also threw nine touchdowns and accumulated 1,027 passing yards during those situations.

Patrick Mahomes and Josh Allen Surprisingly Miss the Top 10

Perhaps the biggest surprise was the absence of two of the NFL’s most recognizable quarterbacks from the top 10.

Buffalo Bills quarterback Josh Allen finished 17th overall, while Kansas City Chiefs superstar Patrick Mahomes ranked 20th.

Advertisement. Scroll to continue reading.

However, both performed strongly in individual categories.

Allen ranked second for EPA per dropback during the final five minutes of close games, averaging 0.251 across 181 dropbacks.

Mahomes, meanwhile, ranked third for EPA per dropback in one-score games, averaging 0.170 across 2,036 dropbacks. The three-time Super Bowl champion also won 29 of his 47 one-score starts during the study period.

The difference comes down to how clutch performance was measured. The study rewarded quarterbacks who improved their efficiency under pressure, rather than simply maintaining a high standard throughout games.

Philadelphia Eagles quarterback Jalen Hurts also stood out, recording the highest winning percentage in one-score games. Hurts won 32 of his 43 starts in such situations, an impressive 74.4% success rate.

What Makes a Quarterback Clutch?

Advertisement. Scroll to continue reading.

The findings highlight how difficult it can be to measure a quarterback’s ability to perform under pressure.

While Burrow led the league in efficiency during the final five minutes of close games, Stafford delivered the strongest overall clutch performance among quarterbacks who played in 2025.

Meanwhile, Mahomes and Allen demonstrated that even quarterbacks outside the overall top 10 can excel in critical moments.

The research used NFL play-by-play data compiled by nflverse, examining fourth-quarter and overtime dropbacks in games separated by eight points or fewer.

Quarterbacks needed at least 150 qualifying dropbacks to be included, with the final rankings combining late-game efficiency, game-winning performance, improvements under pressure, third- and fourth-down conversions, and ball security.

Although no single statistic can settle the debate over the NFL’s most clutch quarterback, the results offer a different perspective on which players have delivered when the stakes are highest.

Advertisement. Scroll to continue reading.

Read More

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You May Also Like

Advertisement